- Federal rule
- Wages paid "free and clear" (29 CFR 531.35)
- Business-cost deductions
- Can't drop pay below minimum wage or cut overtime
- Tipped workers
- No deductions for walkouts, breakage or shortages
- Required uniforms
- The employer's business cost
- Stricter states
- Including California, New York, Massachusetts and Illinois
- Where to complain
- State labor department or the federal Wage and Hour Division
Key characteristics
Minimum wage is protected No business-cost deduction can take you below minimum wage for the hours worked.
Overtime is protected Deductions can't eat into the overtime you earned.
Tipped wages get a hard stop With a tip credit, shortage and breakage deductions aren't allowed at all.
States add more rules Many states ban shortage and breakage deductions or require written consent.
Wage deductions vs related terms
What is a wage deduction?
A wage deduction is money taken out of your pay before it reaches you. Some deductions are normal. Taxes come out of every paycheck, and so can health insurance or other benefits you sign up for.
Others are where the trouble starts. A missing $40 from the till, a broken bottle, a guest who walked out on a tab, a required uniform. Can your employer make you pay for those out of your wages? Often, no. And when they can, there are limits.
The federal rule: your minimum wage is off-limits
Under the federal wage law, your wages must be paid "free and clear" (29 CFR 531.35). In plain words, your employer can't take back any part of your minimum wage or overtime to cover its own costs.
Business costs include uniforms, tools, cash shortages, breakage, damage and customers who don't pay. That's true even if the loss was your mistake. An employer also can't get around the rule by asking you to pay it back in cash instead.
How much can come out for a required uniform?
- Paid exactly minimum wage? Nothing. Any deduction would drop you below $7.25 an hour, so none is allowed.
- Paid $9.25 an hour for 20 hours? You earned $185. The federal minimum for those hours is $145 (20 × $7.25). At most, $40 could come out under federal law.
- Working overtime that week? The deduction can't cut into your overtime pay either.
That's the federal floor. It uses $7.25, but if your state's minimum wage is higher, that higher number is the line.
Tipped workers get extra protection
If your employer pays you a tipped minimum wage, you're already at the legal floor. So the Labor Department says deductions for walkouts, breakage or cash register shortages aren't allowed at all, because they would push you below minimum wage.
States with stricter rules
Federal law sets the floor. Many states go much further, and some ban shortage and breakage deductions outright. Here are four big event markets.
| State | What the state allows |
|---|---|
| California | Shortages, breakage and lost equipment can't be deducted for accidents or honest mistakes, only for a dishonest or willful act or gross negligence. An accusation alone isn't enough. If a uniform is required, the employer pays for it. |
| New York | Employers can't charge you for breakage, cash shortages, fines or other business losses. Uniform costs and upkeep can't be deducted either. |
| Massachusetts | The state's top court ruled in 2011 that an employer can't dock pay for damage to company property, even with the worker's agreement. |
| Illinois | Only with your written consent, given freely at the time the deduction is made. A blanket form signed at hiring generally isn't enough. |
Not on the list? Your state labor department's website will have its own rules on deductions. New York's wage FAQ and California's deductions page are good examples of what to look for.
What about signing a deduction form?
Some employers ask you to sign a policy agreeing to pay for shortages or damage. Signing doesn't make every deduction legal.
What to do if your pay looks short
Mistakes happen, and so do bad policies. Here's how to sort it out.
Check your pay stub
Look for lines like shortage, breakage, uniform, adjustment or fee. Compare your hours and rate against what you were paid.
Ask in writing
Email payroll or your agency and ask what the deduction is for and what rule allows it. Keep the reply.
Keep your own records
Note your shifts, hours, tips and anything you were told about shortages or counts.
File a claim if needed
Your state labor department handles wage claims, and in California that's the Labor Commissioner. The federal Wage and Hour Division also takes complaints.
This is a plain-English summary, not legal advice. State rules change, so check your state labor agency before you sign a deduction policy or file a claim.
Common questions
Best practices
Get the deduction policy in writing Ask before your first shift what can come out of your pay and why.
Be at the count If you're responsible for a till or bar inventory, be there when it's counted.
Common mistakes
Assuming a signed policy makes it legal The federal floor and state law still apply, whatever the form says.
Paying shortages back in cash An employer can't dodge the rules by asking you to repay out of pocket.
Not checking the pay stub A vague "adjustment" line can hide a deduction that shouldn't be there.
Using the federal $7.25 in a high-wage state If your state minimum is higher, that's the line a deduction can't cross.
