Everyone says they’re tipping less. Sit-down tips have barely moved
Surveys describe tipping fatigue. Toast’s card data has full-service tips between 19.1% and 19.4% for two years, while pickup is where tipping slips. For banquet and wedding staff, the sharper question is whether a service charge counts as a tip at all.

Americans keep telling pollsters they are tipping less. At sit-down restaurants, the card data has barely moved. Toast, which processes card payments for restaurants nationwide, put the average full-service tip at 19.1% in the second quarter of 2026, inside the 19.1% to 19.4% range of the past two years, according to Toast’s quarterly tipping data.
Surveys tell the other story. Popmenu, a restaurant-software company, found that the share of Americans who tip servers 20% or more fell from 45% in September 2025 to 41% in March 2026, in a survey of 1,000 consumers reported by Restaurant Dive. Servers describe the same mood. Jo, who posts on TikTok as @mydearest.jo, says a 12-person wedding welcome party ran up a $500 tab and left her $38 in tips, about 7.6%. Guests tipped one by one instead of agreeing on an amount, she says. “If you don’t know tipping math, that should have been a hundred-dollar tip,” she told viewers. The Daily Dot reported her account on Oct. 20. It has not been independently verified, and the venue and city were not named.
Toast’s figures cover card and digital tips at its own restaurants, not all receipts, and cash is excluded. The latest quarter Toast has published is Q2 2026.
For servers and bartenders, the useful split is not tipping versus not tipping. It is where the money is made. Sit-down tables are holding. Pickup and delivery are where tipping slips. And at weddings and galas, the money in question is often a service charge, which may never reach staff as a tip.
- Average full-service tip, Toast card data, Q2 2026
- 19.1%
- Average quick-service tip, Toast, Q2 2026
- 15.8%
- Average takeout tip, Toast, Q2 2026
- 13.8%
- Tip servers 20%+, Popmenu, Sept. 2025 to Mar. 2026
- 45% to 41%
- Pickup orders tipped in 2026, Popmenu data (78% in 2022)
- 62%
Two datasets, two stories
Toast publishes its tip rate every quarter, and the full-service line barely moves. Quick-service sits lower, at 15.8%, and takeout lower still, at 13.8% among customers who leave a tip. Popmenu’s survey asks people about their own habits instead, and the answers lean toward pulling back: it reported that 35% of consumers say they have cut back on how often or how much they tip at restaurants this year.
- Q2 202519.1%
- Q3 202519.2%▲ 0.1% vs previous period
- Q4 202519.2%▲ 0% vs previous period
- Q1 202619.3%▲ 0.1% vs previous period
- Q2 202619.1%▼ 0.2% vs previous period
Source: Restaurant tipping trends · As of Sep 2026
What people say
What sit-down checks show
Where tipping does slip
Why both can be true
Start with what each source counts. Toast measures the average tip rate on card payments. Popmenu asks how people feel, and its question lumps together tipping less often and tipping less. Popmenu’s own figures also move by survey wave: a January 2026 survey put 20%-plus server tippers at 38%, down from 43% two years earlier, per ClickOrlando.
A guest who still leaves 20% on a dinner check may skip the tip on a counter order, a pickup bag or a delivery. Popmenu’s pickup figure points that way, but it is one company’s order data.
Weddings and galas: is it a tip or a service charge?
Event work changes the math. Banquet and wedding bills often carry a service charge or a built-in gratuity, and that fee is not automatically a tip. The IRS now lists banquet staff as a tipped occupation, but the deduction follows how the money is labeled on the invoice and the pay stub. Our service charge vs tip guide and tip-or-service-charge tool show how to read your own paperwork.
Cash is the blind spot. Toast sees cards only, so tip jars at event bars sit outside every figure here, and we found no dataset that measures them. Etiquette advice varies. Fox News quoted etiquette expert Diane Gottsman against tip jars at weddings unless the bar is a cash bar.
- Servers
Know your format. Toast’s Q2 2026 averages run 19.1% at full-service, 15.8% at quick-service and 13.8% on takeout.
- Bartenders
Cash jars fall outside the card data. At a hosted bar, ask whether a gratuity or service charge is already in the host’s contract.
- Catering attendants
Ask how a service charge is distributed and whether it shows up on your pay stub as wages.
Three habits that keep tip questions from becoming disputes:
- Say who gets the service charge. Put it on the invoice and the guest-facing menu, so guests do not tip twice or not at all.
- Track tips by service type. A blended average hides a drop at the counter or in pickup.
- Decide on tip jars before the event. At a cash bar, tell guests what to expect.



